Pentagramma pallida Pilgrimage

Pentagramma pallida Pilgrimage

Pentagramma pallida! Photo: Keir Wefferling

Based on a hot tip from Carrie Tribble, the Rothfels Lab set out one fine Sunday for the foothills of the Sierra Nevada. Driving through rain, we gathered at Table Mountain trailhead (in Tuolumne County) for some general (plants!) and specific (Pentagramma pallida!!) botanizing. Isaac Marck made one or two iNaturalist observations for the day.

Folks checking out some Pentagramma triangularis. Photo: Abby Jackson-Gain
Toxicodendron diversilobum. Photos: Abby Jackson-Gain

Avoiding—mostly—the gorgeous and diversely-lobed Toxicodendron diversilobum (Anacardianceae), we soon encountered our first fern of the day: Pentagramma triangularis ssp. triangularis (Pteridaceae, hemionitid clade of the cheilanthoids).

Pentagramma triangularis. Photo: Keir Wefferling

Another early highlight was Thysanocarpus curvipes (Brassicaceae)….

Beautiful fruits of Thysanocarpus curvipes. Photo: Keir Wefferling

… soon followed by Aspidotis californica (another hemionitid) then Isoëtes nuttallii (Isoëtaceae; yay, Forrest!

Isoëtes nuttalllii just chilling with their friends. Photo: Forrest Freund

But, enough of that; we had driven these many miles not for these non-pallida plants. We were there to see—and collect—the California endemic Pentagramma pallida! So we followed Carrie towards the base of the cliffs of Table Mountain, specifically to the—according to Abby Jackson-Gain—porphyritic (i.e., with phenocrysts/feldspar) columnar basalt and basalt rubble. Nearby associates included Pentagramma triangularis, Quercus, Aesculus californica, Toxicodendron diversilobum, Diplacus aurantiacus, Selaginella hansenii, Myriopteris covillei (?), Pellaea mucronata, Ribes speciosa, and Streptanthus tortuosus. BUT, before we even reached the porphyritic zone, Keir encountered some very strange and wonderful Pentagramma with adaxial farina growing in chaparral, under Adenostoma fasciculatum, Toxicodendron diversilobum, Lepechinia calycina, and Heteromeles arbutifolia. He immediately and provisionally identified this highly distinctive (don’t laugh) morphotype as a hybrid (homoploid? allopolyploid?) between P. pallida and triangularis! The Ploidy Gods and Goddesses were smiling on the rlab that day, so we managed to collect immature sporangia at the right stage for meiotic chromosome counts; stay tuned!

Undescribed new species (????) of Pentagramma. Holy moly. Photo: Forrest Freund.
Adaxial farina on the putative hybrid Pentagramma. Photo: Keir Wefferling
Carl and a happy The Bean, happily exploring the columnar basalt rubble. Photo: Abby Jackson-Gain
People! Photo: Isaac Marck
People! Especially Mike. Photo: Isaac Marck
Checking out the Isoëtes nuttallii. Photo: Abby Jackson-Gain
Isaac and Carrie, looking mighty happy about something. Or everything? Photo: Keir Wefferling
Lasthenia californica! Photo: Abby Jackson-Gain
Columnar basalt rubble! Photo: Abby Jackson-Gain
Table Mountain. Photo: Abby Jackson-Gain
Sooooo mossy. Photo: Keir Wefferling
Triphysaria eriantha ssp. eriantha and Keir’s favorite Plantago. Photo: Keir Wefferling
Erythranthe guttata. Photo: Keir Wefferling
Selaginella hansenii and some mossy moss. Photo: Keir Wefferling
Castilleja. Photo: Keir Wefferling
Syntrichia and friends. Photo: Keir Wefferling



Keir’s trip to Rancho Santa Ana Botanic Garden

Keir visits Santa Cruz Island and speaks at Rancho Santa Ana Botanic Garden

In mid-February, Keir visited Santa Cruz Island to collect ferns, mosses, liverworts, hornworts, and Selaginella. Recognized as a mixing zone for different Pentagramma species and cytotypes, or individuals of a species that express chromosomal variation, since at least 1960, the island presented Keir and his field assistant Eric with the opportunity to collect specimens of P. triangularis and P. viscosa and their hybrids — species Keir referenced in his seminar later that week.

After four days in the California Channel Islands, he found himself a hop, skip and a jump away at the Rancho Santa Ana Botanic Garden where he gave a talk on Feb. 21 about his examinations of polyploid species. Plants with more than two copies of each chromosome evolve differently than diploid plants, which often affects the ecological space in which they grow, or their niche.

Keir, in particular, is interested in instances of this genetic variation in the Western North America genus Pentagramma. By comparing diploid and polyploid species of Pentagramma, Keir is trying to understand whether polyploid species are formed from closely related species or not, and whether polyploid offspring are more or less widely spread than their diploid progenitors.

This has involved far more than the 70 specimens he collected in the Channel Islands — in fact, Keir has been studying 325 individuals of 192 unique specimens for his research. Through an analysis of bioclimatic variables having to do with temperature and precipitation, he has concluded that the distribution of cytotypes on the landscape is not random, with the caveat that his data only takes into account certain aspects of the niche, and doesn’t include things like elevation, soil, or wind patterns.

So what exactly does this niche variation look like? Keir reports that tetraploid P. triangularis have moved into wetter, colder environments, whereas diploid P. triangularis occupy a different, narrower space than their offspring.

Looking North and East toward the Channel Islands National Park


Leptosyne forest


Keir collecting Pentagramma triangularis and P. viscosa — the first collections of the trip


Asterella californica (left), Pentagramma triangularis (right), Rhus ovata flowers (center)


Myriopteris clevelandii


Pentagramma triangularis — check out that adaxial farina!


Keir at the Rancho Santa Ana Botanic Garden